Add New Recipe

Cooking good food in your home away from home!

Location: GoodRVfood > Recipes > Snacks

Amish Peanut Butter

This is my version of the sweet peanut butter spread the Ohio Amish put on every table in their wonderful buffet restaurants. They add a lot more corn syrup than I do to make it thinner and easier to pour or squirt out of a squeeze bottle. I like the thicker version that doesn't drip or make as much of a mess in the RV. This is a versatile spread or topping that goes with almost any meal. Try it on toast at breakfast, sliced apples for a snack, on bread or rolls at lunch or on ice cream after dinner.

Feel free to adjust the quantity of each ingredient to your liking. Play around with it and try it on different foods. It's especially good on graham crackers and reminds me of Fluffer Nutters from my childhood.


 1 cup peanut butter, creamy or chunky
 1 cup Marshmallow Fluff
 2 Tablespoons maple syrup
 1/4 cup light corn syrup


Mix everything together and enjoy. That's all there is to it.

If the mixture is too thick, adding more light corn syrup helps keep it soft and creamy enough to spread without changing the taste too much. The amount of corn syrup is up to your personal preference. I use a little less because I like mine to be a little thicker, about the consistency of soft cream cheese. In the Amish restaurants they add a lot more corn syrup to make it runny enough to work in a squeeze bottle.

Store covered at room temperature. Keeps for weeks in the RV pantry. It gets more stiff when stored in the fridge but 10 or 20 seconds in the microwave turns it soft again.

Serves: 2 to 8
Peanut_Butter Marshmallow_Fluf Maple_Syrup No-Cook Photo

Did we tag something with the wrong thing or missed an important tag? Please tell us using the feedback form below.

Share this Facebook Twitter Delicious Digg Google Bookmarks Reddit Stumbleupon email

Did you see a problem on this page? or Cancel

Please tell us about your favorite recipe that can be prepared in a recreational vehicle kitchen.


You may notice that some of our recipes do not contain exact measurements for all ingredients. Cooking on the road is an art more than a science. We view each recipe as only a suggestion - a starting point for your own personal creativity.

We aren't usually dealing with food chemistry in these recipes since we aren't baking with leavening, etc., so feel free to use as much or as little of any suggested ingredient. Be creative and imaginative! Substitute the foods you like or have available for the ones in the recipes. And if you find something that turns out well for you, please share it with the rest of us.